Ireland has more fisheries inspectors than France and Spain combined - IFPEA
Ireland according to EU list of Union inspectors has 241!
The reported statement on behalf of the Irish Fish Processors & Exporters Association (November 3rd 2022) regarding the number of “SFPA officers” is inaccurate and misleading. The SFPA as of October 2022 employs 82 Sea Fisheries Protection Officers (84 October 2021) who carry out a number of duties, including the protection of consumer safety through ensuring the effective compliance with seafood safety legislation, the monitoring of natural habitats at shellfish harvesting sites, and the promotion of sustainability through compliance with the Common Fisheries Policy.
Editors note: We acknowledge that the SFPA currently employs 82 SFPO's. However we ask the question what role have the 241 named individuals on the EU's list of Union Inspectors have in relation to enforcement for Ireland. Union Inspectors are defined as such - Member States, the Commission as well as the EFCA can nominate members of their staff as Union inspectors in accordance with Council Regulation (EC) No 1224/2009. Union inspectors are fulfilling the specific criteria laid down in Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 404/2011. Union inspectors are mandated, under EU legislation, to carry out inspection and surveillance of fishing activities in European Union waters, outside the zones under the sovereignty of Member States, and in international waters. To this end, in accordance with the provisions of the said regulation, the names of Union inspectors appear on a list published in the Official Journal of the European Union.
Union inspectors may carry out their duties in the framework of JDPs giving effect to SCIPs adopted by the Commission or international control and inspection programmes adopted by regional fisheries management organisations or in the framework of inspection programmes developed by Member States.
Brendan Byrne, CEO of the IFPEA speaking to the Marine Times states that "On a recent trip to the EU institutions, the EU authorities there were keen to point out that Ireland has the highest rate of inspectors in all of Europe, in fact Ireland, I was told has as many fisheries inspectors as France and Spain combined or looking at it another way Ireland has 21 more inspectors than Belgium, Portugal, Netherlands and Denmark combined.
"I challenged the validity of their claims as I could not believe what I was being told and I was duly presented with the List of Union inspectors pursuant to Council regulation (EC) No 1224/2009, it was the publication of 17th January last, so I would imagine it is the most recent data available.
For the record, the following are the EU recorded facts regarding the number of inspectors;
Belgium 14 inspectors, Portugal 21, Netherlands 45, France 105, Spain 140, Denmark 140 and Ireland has 241 inspectors.
Harmonised control is a central theme in the EU Common Fisheries Policy and we all support sustainability and conservation of stocks but we need to look at this more closely and assert what is really going on here. Ireland within their own waters catches approximately 15% -19% of all the fish caught within the Irish EEZ, in other words, it is other member states that catch the greatest majority of the fish stocks in the region of 85% from the Irish EEZ.
The Irish Fish processing sector according to the most recent EUROSTAT figures is worth €622m, while the French sector is worth €4.823 billion, Spain €6.930 billion, Denmark €2.503 billion, Portugal €1.354 billion, Netherlands €1.250 billion and Belgium €961 million which has only 67 km of coastline equal in length to Co Wicklow’s coastline.
We need to carryout a comparative analysis of the fish processing activity to number of inspectors in the different member states to that of Ireland – let’s look at Belgium’s processing activity of €961 million and 14 inspectors, that is equal to one inspector to €68.6m of processing activity in that member state. In Spain there is one inspector to every €49.5m of fish processing activity, France €45.9m, Netherlands €27.7m, Portugal €64.5m
Ireland has one fishery inspector to every €2.5m of fishing activity generated.
For fear of being accused of misrepresenting the facts, let’s do comparative analysis of fishery inspectors to the overall size of the EEZ under the control of the four largest EEZ’s member states in western Europe namely Spain with 569,000 km sq., France 347,600 km sq., Portugal 327,100km sq. with that of Irelands 437,500 km sq. EEZ.
Spain has one fishery inspector for every 4,066 sq. Km of water, France has one to 3,310 sq. km, Portugal has one to 15,576 sq. Km Ireland has one inspector to every 1,815 sq. Km of its EEZ.
How Ireland is exactly managing and deploying this considerable number of inspectors is another matter, and one which has been subject to numerous independent assessments such as the Wolf Report and the most recent that of Price Waterhouse and Coopers (PWC) Report. Observing it from a political perspective, the entire Irish fishing industry requires the immediate resetting of the political narrative, and much more political emphasis needs to be given to the industry if we are to mount a recovery over the next decade.
Norway in 2022, will record 50 years of successive growth, year on year in its seafood industry, and I recently attended an event with a Norwegian delegation and they credit this success to a constant proactive and pro-development Government in Norway, over the past 50 years the various Norwegian Governments have driven their industry to even greater success.
The same cannot be said of us in Ireland, but I feel that is about to change, if we fail to change we will be the last generation to fish our seas. But, the realities of the past 20 years are stark for Ireland, fish processing from 2014 – 2019 has declined by 16% in Ireland, and when you factor in Brexit/TCA it will decline even further from 2020 to present. When you compare that to other member states, the majority of them have increased and grown their fishing industries during the same period.
IFPEA share EU Link showing the list of EU Union Inspectors who may carry out inspections pursuant to Council regulations
The following are the two key points, firstly the this is a publicly available document and is currently available on various EU information sites. The actual title of the document is “ establishing the list of Union Inspectors who may carry out inspections pursuant to Council regulations EC No 1224/2009” . The title of this document is self-explanatory and it is very clear as it lists the various countries and the number of “inspectors as referenced in the document title” . As stated by the IFPEA this document was published in January last, and it would be correct to state it is the most up to date document available, we can also confirm no amendments have been made to the contents of this document in the intervening months, so it is natural to assume it is a true reflection of its purpose , which is to compile a list of Union Inspectors.
The IFPEA wish to share the link here, in order to afford everyone an opportunity to judge for themselves and if they desire to take time and count the number listed for the respective countries , including Ireland - then each person can draw their own conclusions based on the information published and made available to the EU institutions. The following is the actual link. C(2022) 65 final-2022 list Annex.pdf (europa.eu)
The IFPEA hope this clarifies the position.